Silversun Pickups’ epic return to The Wellmont Theater, New Jersey 8/23/25 | Photos & Review

American rock band Silversun Pickups continue to treat New Jersey well. Stopping by what seems to be their favorite venue, the Wellmont Theater in Montclair, NJ, remains a staple on their headlining tours!

While this tour has several different openers throughout its four-month run, NJ was lucky enough to be blessed with the rock throwbacks from Kentucky, Girl Tones!

Sister-duo Kenzie and Laila served as an incredible opener to the night. My introduction to them was their angst-ridden single “Blame,” which served as SiriusXM’s Alt Nation “Impact Track” this summer. Excited to see them for months, the pair certainly did not disappoint!

This performance was Silversun Pickups’ fifth show at The Wellmont Theater, last performing in September 2024 in support of their sixth studio album, Physical Thrills (2022). Though they haven’t released a new project since, the Los Angeles group is still killing it on tour, and playing fan favorites from throughout their impressive 25-year discography. 

The alternative-rock band paid homage to the late legend Ozzy Osbourne with a “Crazy Train” introduction to their hit “Panic Switch,” getting an emotional cheer from the front to the back of the house. 

I got a chuckle out of frontman Brian Aubert’s story about meeting a frog on the streets of Montclair, who asked to live in his throat for warmth before turning into a spider that altered his voice. In short, he shared that although his voice wasn’t in the best shape, there was no way he would cancel his performance at the Wellmont.

It’s always fun to see the songs I’ve known for years, performed live on stage, especially hits like “Substitution” and “Lazy Eye!” Even after the singer explained that his voice may not have been up to his standards, I kept thinking to myself: Wow, they sound even better live than in the studio!

The members of Silversun Pickups are true talents, with dynamic vocals, incredible instrumentals, and lively stage presence. This band is the real deal. 

Here’s to hoping SSPU will return to The Wellmont in another three years (or, perhaps, even sooner!) 

Silversun Pickups’ The Wellmont Theater, Montclair, NJ 8/23/2025 Setlist:

1. Well Thought Out Twinkles
2. It Doesn’t Matter Why
3. Panic Switch
4. Scared Together
5. Little Lover’s So Polite
6. Alone on a Hill
7. Kissing Families
8. Don’t Know Yet
9. Three Seed
10. Substitution
11. Circadian Rhythm (Last Dance)
12. Dots and Dashes (Enough Already)
13. Empty Nest
14. Creation Lake (The Movies cover)
15. Lazy Eye

Photos & Review by Emily McCormack

Keep up with us on social media! Facebook | Instagram | X | YouTube